Monroeville's Best Food

Monroeville is the city that gives you exactly what you want, even when you don’t know what that is yet. I’ve spent more evenings than I care to admit chasing a decent plate through the strip-mall labyrinth, and the results are all below pruning.

You want upscale duck and a bartender who reads your mood, hit Eighty Acres. You want a hoagie the size of a fire extinguisher, Rosecliff has your name on it.

And if you need a dog-approved patio with buffalo chicken mac that actually slaps, Dad's Pub & Grub has your table ready. I ate my way through this town, through chicken parm and pierogies and queso blanco, so you don't have to guess.

These are the spots that survived my wallet and my standards.

Rosecliff Tavern

Highlights
Chicken Parmesan half hoagie
Spicy signature hot sauce
Crispy loaded potato skins
Friendly, attentive staff

I walked into Rosecliff Tavern with low expectations and a mild hankering for something fried. The loaded potato skins showed up crispy, cheesy, and dangerously close to perfect. Then the Chicken Parmesan half hoagie landed, and I nearly forgot my own name. That spicy signature hot sauce deserves its own fan club. The staff hovered just enough to make me feel important without being creepy. Honestly, this place does the small-town tavern thing better than most. They are quick, polite, and actually seem to like their jobs. I left full, happy, and slightly concerned about my arteries. No regrets.

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Pittsburgh.

Dad's Pub & Grub

Highlights
Popeye’s pizza is fantastic
Buffalo chicken mac slaps
Doggy menu on patio
Fast bar service here
Worth the crowded wait

Dad's Pub & Grub is an absolute madhouse on a good night. Worth it, which is saying something because I hate waiting. The Popeye's pizza is fantastic, maybe the best weird crossover I've had. Buffalo chicken mac? I'm not sure a dish can slap, but if it can, this one does. The bar service moves fast, so you can get a drink while you stand there starving. Plus they have a doggy menu on the patio, so my prickly little mutt got a snack too. That's how you win a customer's heart forever.

You might also want to check out the best neighborhoods in Pittsburgh.

Coast and Main Seafood and Chophouse

Highlights
Great service, excellent food
Kelly the server shines
Perfect birthday dinner spot
Worth every penny
Bring a jacket though

Coast and Main feels like a real treat, the kind you save for a birthday or a massive promotion. The food is excellent and the service nearly perfect. Kelly, our server, glowed brighter than the lights, and I didn't rent a single napkin from her. She made the evening flow. The place is upscale but not obnoxious. Bring a sweater because they keep it arctic cold, which is fine if you're dressed like an actual seal. We dropped plenty of cash and considered it money well spent. Worth every penny, and I mean that sincerely.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Akron.

The Coxcomb

Highlights
Fresh, huge portions, fair prices
House sauces steal the show
Homemade pierogies worth the trip
Clean, welcoming, family-friendly vibe
Honey balls: fried dough perfection

The Coxcomb is the kind of place that makes you suspicious at first because the prices are fair and the servings are enormous. The pierogies are homemade, and they alone justify you driving 40 minutes out of your way. Their house sauces show up on everything and steal the show, like a loud uncle at Thanksgiving. I had those honey balls for dessert, fried dough perfection is the only accurate phrase. Clean plates, clean space, families everywhere. It feels welcome without pretending to be fancy. I left full, satisfied, and bewildered that this place isn't busier. Get there before it is.

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Pittsburgh.

Eighty Acres Kitchen & Bar

Highlights
Unique dishes, attentive service
Excellent bartender, great cocktails
Lovely owners, sophisticated menu
Worth the trip, truly
Delicious duck and chowder

Eighty Acres is a proper grown-up restaurant. The menu is sophisticated but doesn't require a decoder ring. I ordered duck and the chowder, and both made me forget what I was thinking. My bartender built a cocktail that matched my mood perfectly, or at least did a great job of lifting it. The owners walked around and chatted like they genuinely cared about my opinion. That alone is a rare streak. Yes, you have to drive beyond the obvious strip malls for it. Worth the trip, truly. The price stings a little, but you won't complain once you taste it.

You might also want to check out the best areas to live in Pittsburgh.

Mintt Indian Cuisine - Monroeville

Highlights
Best Indian food around
Friendly staff, spotless space
Aroma fills the air
Now my favorite spot

The moment you walk into Mintt, the aroma bombs you in the safest possible way. Warm spices, clean air, good vibes. Their Indian food is the best I've found in this town, and I've tried more than my abdomen would ever admit. The staff are cheerful and the floors glow. My usual order arrives fast, generous, steady. The place is absolutely spotless, which shouldn't be an outlier in the Monroeville game, but it is. Now it's simply my favorite spot when I want to taste something beyond chicken fingers. Keep mint, whatever you're doing.

You might also want to check out the best shopping malls in Pittsburgh.

Labriola Italian Markets at Monroeville

Highlights
Fast Boar's Head hoagies
Big homemade dessert selection
Wedding soup broth fails
Loaded candy and drinks
Lunch or dinner grab

Labriola Italian Markets is a grab-and-go spot with brawny hoagies made from Boar's Head. Fast, reliable, and if you want lunch or dinner without effort, they hand it over quickly. Their dessert case is enormous and I have yet to see all of it, but I'm trying. The wedding soup broth, though? I will not apologize, that broth is mostly like warm water with a sad attitude. Skip that and load up on candy and drinks. The vibe is basic grocery with a warm soul. I'll keep coming, but I'll skip the soup.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Youngstown.

Johnny's Italian Dining

Highlights
Fresh food worth waiting for
Tenderloin tips are unforgettable
Immaculate, timeless Italian atmosphere
Reasonably priced, incredible service

Johnny's Italian Dining feels like walking into a time machine wearing a moustache. Immaculate and timeless, it's the kind of spot where you expect someone to bring you a Gibson and a napkin the size of a bedsheet. The tenderloin tips left a memory on my tongue that survived until breakfast. Nothing feels rushed. The prices are reasonable for what you get, which is honestly rare these days. Service bordered on supernatural. They anticipated drafts, refills, cravings, all of it. Fresh, warm, Italian comfort. Try to walk past dessert if you possess a soul that wills to say no. I could not.

You might also want to check out the best store in Pittsburgh.

Mad Mex Monroeville

Highlights
Queso blanco steals the show
Manager goes above and beyond
Bigger inside than it looks
Gobblerito wins wife's approval
Worth splurging for dessert

Mad Mex has this narrow street presence that lies to you. Go inside, and the place expands like a clown car with better lighting and a forgiving heart. The queso blanco is undeniably the main character before your food arrives. The manager stopped by our table and solved a problem I didn't even know we had; that's the actual hero move. My partner ordered the Gobblerito and gave it a thumbs up. Then me. We split dessert because I have bad self-control, and I'm glad. Splurging here is easy, and do it. The bar is fine, patio is fine, crowd is fine when there's not showing up.

You might also want to check out the best food in Canton.

Penn Gyros & Kebab

Highlights
One-stop craving fix
Flavor-packed generous portions
Authentic Mediterranean favorites
Tasty sauces, fresh dips
Worth every order

Penn Gyros & Kebab is my unironic dirt-bag hero when nothing else sounds right. One plate covers gyro, kebab, rice, sauce, pita, and a mood entirely. Flavors are deep, portions are aggressive. The Mediterranean staples all come out at a good temperature. Their sauces are basically good condiments, and the fresh dips make me happy. I've had the large and the large is still not enough. Everything I've ordered has come out fast and probably as you watch. It's not fine dining; it's fine eating.

You might also want to check out the best mover in Pittsburgh.

The Green Mango

Highlights
Fast, friendly service
Clean, welcoming space
Delicious Tom Kha soup
Perfect Thai iced tea
Great for small groups

The Green Mango is real relaxed. I took a table for two, even though it said tables for a few. They served me in minutes, a luxury I do not fully respect until I get it. The Tom Kha soup I ordered was one sweet, coconut, tangy jolt to the temple. The Thai iced tea arrived brilliantly orange and creamy sweet. Not too sweet. Service is effusively friendly, and the entire room is clean and calm. It's a good spot for a quiet gathering of maybe six friends. I left refreshed and silently I planned my next return.

You might also want to check out the best florist in Pittsburgh.

Eat'n Park

Highlights
Whale of a Cod
Wonderful salad bar
Free smiley cookie
Breakfast buffet weekends
Excellent pie varieties

Eat'n Park is the classic Pennsylvania diner chain that beats around forever. Their Whale of a Cod is ridiculous by name but in remembrance, it's big and flaky and frying up right. The salad bar is old-school, and that's a good thing, plus their weekend breakfast buffet was not a lie. The pie selection is genuinely massive, and I'll make appro hours over it. You get a free smiley cookie at the end, which feels like a warm reward for being yourself. It's not everything, but it is what it is. And I mean that kindly.

You might also want to check out the best roofers in Pittsburgh.